Recoil through frames
Something found deep in a chain of frames can answer what an earlier frame could not. Recoil carries it back up, one frame at a time, and asks again only the frames it fits; the others pass it on at no cost.
NOTE
How to use it is in Recoil. This page keeps its design: the need, its open calls, what comes later, and the case its tests hold it to, which Five dolls, one kid runs with a real reader.
Need
A decision often rests on evidence reached through several crossings, and each frame tests one of them. A frame knows where its text came from, by each span's source, and nothing more: not who read it next, nor where the chain began. When the last frame finds what an earlier one lacked, nothing carried it back, and asking every frame again spent every call again.
Open calls
- The ablation already made: a successor's ablation is its frame's baseline call, the same prompt to the same battery. A record names its frame's hash, and
check_recordsrefuses another frame's records, so reading it there would be a method change. - What a decision climbs as: the frame's name and the label it reads, such as
middle doll reads boy. Whether a carried decision climbs by itself, or waits for its author, is the caller's.
Later
- Siblings: frames of the same grain side by side, joined so that a piece offered to one is offered to its neighbours too. One step aside from the start frame, to the frames quoting a text it quotes, is built; siblings a frame declares, or that share its locus, wait for a case that needs them.
- Grouping by locus: frames grouped by where their relation acts. A walk already offers a piece first where it is most likely to fit, by the vectors its caller gives (Recoil); a locus is free text, so frames sharing one are not yet grouped.
- Offering down: a piece only climbs, so one found above its hole is never offered to it.
- Reframing down: going up, only a frame whose question changes can reframe, often the root; going down, a reframed frame can reframe the frames whose question came from it, each opened as a reframing in turn.
- Shuffled sentences: sentences shuffled within a frame, or across frames and grains, each shuffle a frame of its own. The walk follows each text by its hash, so it holds while every sentence moves whole.
Tests
The case is a set of five nesting dolls, after the boy and the girl that meaning representations have always started with. Each doll is a frame that quotes the doll it came out of, and all are painted alike, the largest as girlish as paint gets; but paint says nothing of who a doll is, only a doll's own word does. The second doll's word is lost, and turns up in the smallest.
- The slip climbs from the smallest doll past the fourth and third, which pass it on, fits the second doll's hole, and climbs on to the largest, which passes it on too: its hole wants a role, not a statement.
- The smallest doll quotes the largest's mark, so the largest is reached by many routes and visited once. Without the largest's frame, both quotes of it are the frontier, and the walk is not complete.
- The second doll asked again with its word is firm after one light run, and carried: a boy by its own word, unclear without it, whatever the paint. Its ablation's prompt is the doll as it was unpacked, byte for byte.
- A reader that guesses from the paint when the word is cut answers girl, where the frame allows only unclear: coupled but misaligned, caught.
- The second doll's decision,
second doll reads boy, climbs to the largest and fits. The set was taken for girls by its paint, so a boy inside, by its own word, needs a label it lacks: a reframing, and the set as asked stands. - Where the second doll is asked about its chipped base instead, its word still fits, but the successor reads cooled, and nothing climbs.
- A reader that wavers on its first run is asked twice more, and disengages once two firm runs read alike; one that never settles stops at the most runs, and the gate stops with it. Kept runs are not asked again.